Showing posts with label Israeli elections. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Israeli elections. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 18, 2019

If Only I Could Be Less Blind; If Only I Knew What To Find ( Phil Lesh & Jerry Garcia - "Mindbender Confusion's Prince")


For some reason, when Israel has elections, I feel compelled to reach out to a few friends who have made Aliyah.  This week was no different. I reached out to a few of my friends, a Brit and several Americans all of whom are all politically quite savvy and quite cynical. I spoke to them about a week before the elections and then immediately after the returns were finalized. With the results in, it appears at this point that Prime Minister Netanyahu does not have enough support to form a government. Perhaps the most fascinating result of the election was the fact that friends on the political left of the issue of peace and Palestinians and friends on the political right of the issue of peace and the Palestinians were both hopeful that Bibi would not remain Prime Minister. Both pointed out that Bibi has a cynical pattern: increasing tensions with Hamas which allows Bibi to threaten or militarily engage Hamas. My friends explained that this decision to respond militarily is completely justified; both sides point out the fascinating coincidence that tensions and incursion seem to occur around an election. They pointed out that a couple of weeks before this election there was increased tension with Hamas. My friends explained that rising tensions and a military incursion allow Netanyahu to portray himself as “Israel’s Protector”.  My friends also pointed out that Bibi tends to make extravagant promises regarding Israel’s security. Approximately a week before the election, Israelis heard President Trump’s talking about a defense treaty with Israel and Netanyahu’s pledged to annex the Jordan Valley. “So”, I asked, “What’s different this time?”
This week's Parsha is Ki Tavoh. For the past several Parshiot, Moshe has been listing and explaining all the precepts and laws. Last week's Parsha and the first part of Ki Tavoh explains the rewards. We will inherit the land; we will keep the land. Our enemies will be rendered weak. We will be fruitful and multiply. However, the second half of the Parshah explains all the curses that would befall us if we neglect to observe these laws. Every curse, of course, is the diametric opposite the previous blessings. So if we were promised bountiful harvests and many children, then our curse will be drought, famine, and bareness. Traditionally, the Aliyot that contain the curses are read in a softer voice. However, as horrible as these curses are, we must understand that it is up to us. We can either follow these laws or not, and as a result, we will bear the consequences of our actions. This is not necessarily a bad lesson for us as well as our children to learn. We are responsible for our actions, and we must bear responsibility for the consequences of those actions.
            One of the curses is most poignant given what my friends in Israel were explaining to me regarding cynical and corrupt leadership.  Arur Mashgeh Iveir Ba'Derech, Va'Amar Kol Ha'Am Amen - Accursed is one who causes a blind person to go astray on the road. And the entire nation said 'Amen" (Deut 27:18). If we read this literally then we are talking about a guide or a seeing-eye dog that would lead the blind astray. However, this curse is symbolic. We know that the Torah is light and the word Derech (way) is usually in combination with the Way of the Lord (God's Laws). On a metaphorical level, the curse is upon those leaders of a community that causes the less knowledgeable to go astray. If that knowledge causes those who are blind to go astray, then that leader should be cursed. Implicit to that statement is that the one who causes the blind to go astray sees the light, has the knowledge and teaches or guides the community away from God. Our Talmudic Sages offer an Aggadah about the teachers/Rabbis who were the leaders of their communities. "If there are two teachers, one who covers much ground but is not exact, and one who does not cover much ground but is exact, Rav Dimi b. Nehardea maintained that the one who is exact and does not cover much ground is to be appointed. The reason? A mistake once implanted (in the mind or in behavior) remains [a mistake]. (Talmud Baba Batra 21a-b). The Talmudic sages essentially understood the first rule in education. It is terribly difficult to undo that which has already been incorrectly taught.
It appears that the Talmudic Sages also understood quite a bit about Israeli political campaigns as well. My friends, both on the “right” and the “left” explained that at least half of the country has started to see that the Prime Minister takes a cynical approach to campaigning and governance. They explain that at least half of Israel has become aware that he is concerned about remaining in power and avoiding any corruption charges rather than solving the issues that matter to at least half of Israelis. They also sensed that Bibi’s disdain for democratic institutions including the courts, the press, and Israel’s Declaration of Independence had become evidently troubling to many Israelis. My friends all agreed that it doesn’t bode well for a leader of democracy to outwards and cynically express disdain for the very institutions that ought to be defended. Nor does it bode well for a leader of a democracy to divide and weaken the very institutions that make Israel such an incredibly unique and special place. As we hung up, they were all left wondering if there will be a new Prime Minister and if not, hopefully, this Prime Minister received the message transmitted by friends and the rest of the electorate.  

Peace,
Rav Yitz

Tuesday, March 17, 2015

Big Boss Man Can't You Hear Me When I Call ( Smith & Dixon "Big Boss Man")



Two news stories have captured our children’s attention. One has to do with the current election in Israel and one has to do with a potential Democratic female candidate in the United States. Both Israel Prime Minister Netanyahu and Former First Lady, Former Senator, Former Secretary of State Hilary Clinton have a core constituency who deeply believe that their candidate can do no wrong. Yet the Israeli Prime Minister finds himself fighting for his political life in elections that many Israelis believe to be a referendum on Bibi Fatigue. As for Mrs. Clinton, a recent news story and ensuing apology about her use of her private email address when conducting affairs of state, have many rolling their eyes thinking about Clinton Fatigue.  Much of this fatigue is a result of both trying to achieve power and say or do whatever they need to in order to energize their constituency and remain in power. Every so often, this leads to questionable ethical behavior. Interestingly enough, the electorate understands that great leadership and perhaps statesmanship has as much to do with ethical behavior as well as the actual ritual of governing. A superficial reading of a Talmudic Midrash supports his idea. A potential convert asks the great sage Shammai to teach him the entire Torah while standing upon one leg. Shammai abruptly dismisses him. The potential convert then seeks the great sage Hillel and makes the same request. Rather than dismissing him, Hillel responds, “What is hateful to you, do not do to your fellow man. This is the entire Torah, all of it; the rest is commentary. Go and study it.” (Shabbat 31a). Certainly we could understand this Midrash as a preference of the ethical rather than the ritual. However, the brevity of Hillel’s statement implies that ethical and ritual are linked.
This week’s Parsha is VaYikra, the first Parsha of the Book of Leviticus, -Sefer VaYikra. Unlike the first book of the Torah, Breishit (Genesis) and the first part of Shmot (Exodus) which was written in a narrative form, and the second Part of Shmot which listed laws as well as the instructions for building the Mishkan (the Tabernacle); the Book of Leviticus focuses upon the Priestly class and their responsibility within Jewish biblical society. Therefore, VaYikra does not focus upon a story, nor laws that are geared towards B’nai Yisroel. Rather the laws are aimed at the Leviim, their responsibilities, the precise manner in which sacrificial offering are made, the requirements for offerings, the requirements for the Leviim as well as the requirements for B’nai Yisroel in order to bring offerings. From Parsha VaYikra and for that matter the entire book, we derive numerous ethical teachings all of which is necessary for a people and a society to achieve a sense of holiness. Perhaps just as important is that we derive the importance that Judaism cannot be just about the “letter of the law” but there must be some ethical value behind the letters. After God “calls” out to Moshe, we read the list and the details concerning Korbonot-sacrifices. Which animals should be sacrificed, how many, for which reason, who is obligated, and how to do it.

Again God reminds of the purpose of “sacrifice”. The word Korbon (sacrifice) connotes “approach”. This is based upon the three-lettered Hebrew root KaReiV, which means approach. So we are making sacrifices as a means of approaching God. However, after reading this litany of detailed minutia, we might lose sight of the purpose of sacrifice. Korbon (sacrifice) is not only a means of approaching God; it is a means to approach our fellow man.  The end of the Parshah reminds us of this. Nefesh Ki Techeteh U’Ma’Alah M’Al B’Adonai V’Chichesh Ba’Amito “God spoke to Moses saying: If a person will sin and commit treachery against God by lying to his comrade….”(Lev.5:21-25). We draw closer to God via our fellow man. Unethical behavior towards our fellow man effects our relationship to God. Unethical behavior renders us impure and causes blemish to our character and to our spirit. We know that God only accepts blemish free offerings. If we are spiritually impure, because of unethical behavior, how can we hope to approach God? Like the great sage Hillel implied, the Parshah demonstrates that the Ethical and the Ritual are linked. Both aspects form a symbiotic relationship with each other. Together they form Torah. Separation of the Ethical and the Ritual leaves the individual and Torah incomplete. However, struggling and, hopefully, integrating both allows the individual to approach God as well as others through dignity and respect.

Whether or not Netanyahu wins or loses, forms a coalition or not; he has been weakened as a leader and a statesman. Whether Mrs. Clinton runs for the Democratic Nomination or not, she is more vulnerable than she once was. Ironically, it didn’t have to be this way for either leader. If they could have thought more about how their actions and words would be perceived by their respective electorate, they might have realized that ritual expediency: doing what is “simpler” or speaking in the most provocative and incendiary manner does not necessarily help achieve the ultimate goal. Rather the ritual and the ethical are always linked. 

Peace,
Rav Yitz