Showing posts with label "So Many Roads". Show all posts
Showing posts with label "So Many Roads". Show all posts

Thursday, December 27, 2018

Born Where The Sun Don't Shine, And I Don't Deny My Name (Robert Hunter & Jerry Garcia)



After our children have spent time studying the Holocaust in school, I always asked each of them a question. I always wondered at what point did our children sense that Jews in Europe began to be de-humanized, and is there one image that symbolized that dehumanization. The Yellow Star of David was a symbol of dehumanization, much of the anti-Semitic imagery and language served to dehumanize the Jews. Suggestions in language that Jews were vermin or images of an octopus with its tentacles wrapped around the earth and squeezing out all its wealth also served to dehumanize the Jews. However, for my children, perhaps the tattooed numbers upon Jews entering into work camps and concentration camps, however, seemed to be the most powerful moments of dehumanization. When asked why, each said that the numbers were an attempt to take away their names, their own individual identity. Last week, our children saw stunning images at the border between Mexico and The United States. As more and more people try to enter the United States’ southern border and U.S. immigration officials have figured out a solution to avoid the risk of losing children if and when they are separated from their parents. The U.S. immigration officials have started writing numbers upon parents  and children. Numbers have started to replace names as a form of identity for those Spanish speaking people trying to cross the border from Mexico to the United States.

This Shabbat we begin the Book of Exodus with the Parsha Shmot. Jacob’s twelve sons have died. With the passing of that generation of immigrants, a new Pharaoh took over and did not have the same relationship with Joseph’s family as the previous Pharoah. He enslaves Jacob’s descendants. Then in the second chapter of Shemot, a baby is born from the tribe of Levi, He is hidden and eventually found by the Pharoah’s daughter and raised as Egyptian and given the named Moshe. The grown boy sees an Egyptian beating a slave and kills the Egyptian taskmaster. He sees two Hebrew slaves arguing and again gets involved. However, he is identified and known as someone who has killed a taskmaster.  Moshe flees Goshen and Egypt and arrives in Midian. He marries and becomes a shepherd for his father in law. While serving as a shepherd he encounters God at the Burning Bush. During this moment of revelation, God tells Moshe that he has been chosen to lead the people from slavery to freedom. Moshe hesitatingly accepts the jobs and he returns to Egypt. Moshe meets his brother Aaron, and together they meet Pharaoh and makes the first request to release the slaves.

Parsha Shemot begins V’Eilah SHmot B’nai Yisroel, these are the names of the Children of Israel (Yaakov) HaBaim Mitzraima Eit Yaakov Ish U’Veito Bau- who were coming to Egypt with Jacob, each man, and his household. Each son and each tribe is mentioned. Keeping in mind that each tribe received a blessing at the very end of Breishit, each tribe represents some innate quality and value that is vital to the people as a whole. Each name is a source of identity to those people. With the appearance of a new Pharaoh, these children have swelled in population: Paru V’Yishretzi VaYirbu V’Ya’Amtzu B’Meod Meod V’Timaleh HaAretz Otam - fruitful, teemed increased and became strong - very very much so; and the land became filled with them. The new Pharaoh sees the increasing minority population as a threat. He doesn't see individuals, he sees a group, a tribe, a people.  In the second chapter of the Shemot we read narratives how Moshe receives his name an the meanings of the names of Moshe’s sons. When Moshe encounters God, the first thing Moshe asks of God is Ma Shmo What is His name? Commenting on the importance of Shem - name, the Chatam Sofer, the late 18th/ early 19th-century commentator taught “Be careful not to change your name, language, and do not dress like non-Jews, Heaven forbid. This alludes to the fact that Jacob arrived in Egypt  Shalem (intact) and for Bnai Yisroel to remain intact, and complete, they must not change their names (Shem), their language (Lashon)  and their dress (Malbush). A name is one of the three legs upon which identity rests.

Names are sacred. Names are empowering. Parents name their children. Pet owners name their pets. To give another a name is a source and perhaps a demonstration of power and authority. Receiving a name or a title could be empowering when it separates and elevates the individual. However, receiving a name or a title could also be incredibly demeaning.So when we see those in power writing numbers upon the arms of the powerless; we see an act of dehumanization. We see a people telling a powerless group that they are insignificant and have no identity. Treating them like second-class citizens could be considered acceptable and perhaps expected. As our children continued to watch those immigration officers write numbers upon the wrists of those immigrant children, we couldn’t help but think how dangerously weak the beacon of liberty and democracy has become.    


Peace,Rav Yitz


Wednesday, January 18, 2017

Born Where The Sun Don't Shine, And I Don't Deny My Name (Robert Hunter & Jerry Garcia "So Many Roads"



Among the more irritating qualities of teenagers is their attempt to convey a lack of intellectual curiosity. Certainly this attitude is something that neither my wife nor I model nor condone. Maybe it’s not all teenagers all the time. Maybe this lack of intellectual curiosity exists in some teenagers some of the time.  As parents, there is perhaps no greater frustration than watching our children receive an assignment in English class that involves reading a book and then writing an essay or a paper about some aspect of the book. The frustration sets in immediately as our children’s criteria for choosing the book is the number of pages, the size of the print, and the degree of difficulty.  If I suggest a book, I can all but guarantee that our child will find some inane reason not to read it. Well, I am here to say that we had a momentous breakthrough. Our daughter received a list of choices for her book assignment. One of the choices offered was Lawrence Hill's The Book of Negroes. I had read the book, and I liked the book. Because the book told the story of a young girl’s life of from childhood to old age, and that much of the book involved American history, I felt that our daughter would be able to connect to the text and enjoy it. I explained that when the Book of Negroes was published; it was published in the U.S. with a different title. In the US the book was entitled: Someone Knows My Name.  When she asked why, I told her that was for her to figure out. Amazingly enough my non-answer piqued her interest. Sure she hemmed and hawed, but she read the book. More importantly, she asked questions about the book, she expressed interest in the book. When she finished the book she could appreciate the U.S. title. She even figured out that issues of race are very different in the U.S. compared to Canada, and the term Negro became a derogatory term within the African American community in a very different way than in Canada. She even thanked me for suggesting it to her in the first place. I was shocked, and I was very proud of her.  She exhibited genuine intellectual curiosity and suddenly she became an interesting person with whom I could discuss issues.
This week we begin the second book of the Torah; the Book of Exodus – Sefer Shmot, literally translated into “The Book of Names”. This second book begins with the Parsha Shmot – The Book of Names. The first few verses essentially recount the ending of the Book of Genesis. Shmot re-iterates names of Jacobs’ sons and the fact that Jacob and his sons came to Egypt. We are reminded that Jacob had already died. We are reminded that next generation, Jacob’s sons (including Yosef) passed away. A new king assumes the mantle of power and does not know of Yosef’s great deeds. Instead, the new Pharaoh believed that this foreign population was tantamount to a fifth column. Therefore this tribe must be enslaved in order to prevent their uniting with Egypt’s external enemies. We read about the birth and growth of Moses, and his flight to Midian. We read about his becoming a husband, a shepherd, a father. We learn of his epiphany with the Burning Bush and God’s instructions plan to redeem B’nai Israel from slavery and Moshe’s role in the redemptive process.
Considering, that this is a completely new Sefer, a new Book of the Torah, and that dominant theme of this new book is redemption from slavery and the national revelation at Mt. Sinai, why should the text be known as a Book of Names and why should it begin with a re-iteration of the names of Jacobs’ sons: V’Eilah Shmot  B’nai Yisroel Ha’Baim Mitzrayaima Eit Yaakov Ish U’Veito Ba’u- And these are the name of the Children of Israel who were coming to Egypt with Jacob, each man and his household came, Reuven Shimon, Levi, Yehuda; Issachar, Zebulun , and Benjamin; Dan Naphtali; Gad and Asher. We don’t normally begin a new book with conjunction, especially the conjunction “And”.  Instead of beginning the Parsha and the Book of Shmot with Eilah (These), the Parsha begins with V’Eilah (And these). Also, we know, based upon the conclusion of Sefer Breishit that the sons, along with Jacob, arrived in Egypt decades before (Gen. 46:8-30). Why do these opening verses repeat the concluding verses of the previous book? RaMBaN, (the great 12th century Spanish doctor, commentator and Halachist), and R’ Bachya (late 13th early 14th century Torah commentator), explain that the conjunction which begins the Parsha purposefully connects this new book to the previous book.  “B’nai Yisroel”, the term now used for the extended tribe owe their existence and their future existence to V’Eilah –“and these”…. these sons of Jacob, these sons who were “with Jacob” in his descent into Egypt. Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsh (19th Cent. Germany) explains that these twelve sons and their resulting twelve tribal families were intimately attached to Jacob, and this was the secret of Israel’s strength and survival in Egypt. Although each son had his own family, he remained connected and united with Jacob. Implicit to these opening versus we understand that the secret to B’nai Israel’s survival in Egypt as slaves: past, present and future were connected through values and covenant of the name of Jacobs twelve sons, Jacob, and his father and grandfather, Isaac and Abraham. The strength of those connections, the strength of being connected to the past with an eye towards a hopeful and positive future kept B’nai Israel spiritually free despite physical hardship and bondage.
The names explicitly mentioned, Jacob and his son’s, stood for something. Implicitly, these names stood for and symbolized a covenantal relationship with God. These names stood for inheriting a land, as well as making a great name for itself. For their descendants, the names gave them an identity, an identity that kept them spiritually free despite their physical bondage.  Our daughter learned the same lesson from The Book of Negroes. People’s names matter. A given name matters as does the surname. Often times, a given name reflects the parents’ hopes and dreams for that child. A given name expresses a parents’ hope of whom the child should emulate, and whose values the child should grow to aspire to and embody. However a surname tells the child where she from and to whom she belongs. A surname provides a backdrop, a narrative for the child to be part of and to expand. Now that she has become a bit more intellectually curious, maybe she will be more enthusiastic to make her name part of her family’s narrative.

Peace
Rav Yitz    

Wednesday, March 16, 2016

And You Don't Seem To Hear Me When I Call (Robert Hunter & Jerry Garcia - "So Many Roads")



Amid the newsworthy coverage of Prime Minister Trudeau’s visit to the White House, amid the bluster and noise that is Donald Trump’s campaign for the Republican nomination, amid the relaxed joy of spring training and the anticipation of another baseball season, my children came home from school last week talking about another terrorist stabbing in Israel. These random attacks have been occurring for months but for some reason this particular attack was very different. The story made the news cycle for a minimal amount of time. No one from our circle of friends in New York, Boston, Los Angeles, San Diego, Toronto, or Israel, knew the young man., He wasn’t Jewish. Yet when our children came home to talk about the incident, for some reason, the tragedy called out to all of us in a slightly different manner than what we have grown accustomed to. Maybe we have all grown accustomed to Israelis, and Jews, suffering at the hands of these terrorists in Israel. Certainly when a terrorist attack occurs outside of Israel and all different types of people are killed (most recently Paris and California), the news coverage is very thorough and the story occupies a large part of the news cycle. Taylor Force was graduate of West Point, a veteran of several tours of duty in Afghanistan, a Vanderbilt University MBA student who was studying Israel’s entrepreneurial environment that led it to be call “Start Up Nation”. However last week Taylor Force was murdered at the hands of a Hamas terrorist in Jaffa. Those of us exposed to the western press, heard about the story but it received minimal coverage in the mainstream media. It seems that the mainstream media didn’t quite hear enough in order to cover the story or maybe the story itself didn’t call out to the “right” people so that it would receive appropriate coverage. Yes the State Department made a statement, albeit a typically diplomatic statement condemning the violence on both sides of the conflict. Vanderbilt University issued a statement as did the Hillel at Vanderbilt’s campus. Interestingly enough many Jewish educators, and Rabbis took to Twitter and Facebook to offer condolences to Taylor’s family and condemn this heinous act. Even our children heard the calling of another senseless act of terror.  

This Shabbat we begin the third book of the Torah with the Parsha of the same name, VaYikra otherwise known as Leviticus. Unlike Breishit and parts of Shmot which were narratives or other parts of Shmot with were a series of legislative acts, teaching us law after law; VaYikra is something very different. We are all able to relate to narrative and to stories. We can even read the law that governed biblical Jewish society and admire the laws’ humanity, admire the ethical lessons the law tried to teach or even admire the people that the law tried to protect. However when we begin Parshat VaYikra, we all have a problem connecting to the concept of Korbonot, the term used to describe animal sacrifices. We all have difficulty connecting to the various types of Korbonot; the animals permitted for an offering, and the technical aspects of the offering. Do we really need to know how to check of the animal, and to slaughter the animal? Do we need to read about sprinkling the blood of the animal; roasting the animal, and finally eating the animal? Parsha VaYikra and in fact the entire book of Leviticus truly challenges those of us living in modernity. If for no other reason, we are challenged because we don’t have a Mishkan, we don’t have a Holy Temple and we don’t make animal sacrifices. We all understand the concept of proximity within a relationship. A KoRBon from the Hebrew root KeReV, means to draw near, to approach. A Korbon was our ancestors’ way of drawing closer to God. However even before God teaches Moshe all the mitzvot concerning Korbonot, God does something very unique, something that God had never done before to Moshe as a way of drawing him closer.

The first word of the Parsha and the book already creates an environment of “concern for proximity”. VaYikrah El Moshe, VaYidaber Adoshem Eilav M’Ohel Moed Leimor – He called out to Moshe and Hashem spoke to him from the Tent of the meeting saying. (Lev. 1:1). God called, God spoke and God said; three very similar verbs yet slightly different. One calls out to a person when trying to get his/her attention. Rashi, the great 11th century French commentator, offers several explanations. First this “calling” is Lashon Chiba – a language of endearment. God was calling out to Moshe in a loving gentle manner, and only to Moshe, no one else since no one else heard God’s call. Once called and Moshe approaches, God “speaks” to him. Speaking to someone assumes a partnership or a dialogue. This partnership might not be 50/50, and the dialogue might not be an equally two sided dialogue but it assumes a response. However, “telling” someone to do something neither assumes partnership nor dialogue but rather the transmission of information or instruction without questions. For the first time, God Vayikra el Moshe. God called out to Moshe as a means of singling him out for a vital task: to instruct the Kohanim and the people the appropriate way for them to draw near to God – Korbon. As important as God’s calling out to Moshe, was the fact that Moshe was able to hear God’s call. Moshe was that sensitive, and in tune with his relationship to God.

Sometimes we are not able to hear so well. Sometimes we don’t hear God’s calling out to us. Sometimes God calls out to us for good and sometimes we are called to bear witness. Our silence is a manifestation of fact that we failed to hear a “calling”. When the press misses the story, and focuses upon the bluster of an individual; it fails to hear the calling of its purpose – to bear witness to injustice and evil. Interestingly enough, the world, or at least those connected to the world, connected to digital media, those who pay attention and listen and are able to cut through the noise and really hear the “calling” heard a university mourning, heard a family mourning, heard Army friends mourning, heard classmates mourning. When Prime Minister Netanyahu called Taylor’s family and offered his condolences, an entire country, a country that was not even Taylor’s mourned for him as well. Thankfully our children were able to hear and bear witness as well. VaYitrzror Bitzror HaChayim et Nishmato - May Taylor’s soul be bound up in the bond of life.

Peace,
Rav Yitz  

Monday, January 4, 2016

So Many Roads I Know All I Want Is One To Take Me Home (Robert Hunter & Jerry Garcia - "So Many Roads")



Earlier this week, there were two legal cases, and two government responses in two different countries. In Saudi Arabia, a Shia cleric, speaking to the 20% Shia minority in Saudi Arabia, was accused of, and convicted of terrorism. He was found guilty and beheaded. As a result Iran, a Shia country, burned the Saudi Embassy in Tehran and both countries have cut off diplomatic relations with each other. In Israel, a right wing Israeli extremists were convicted of murdering a Palestinian family (both parents and a baby died while the Right Wing Jewish group burned the house down). One within the group was caught, tried and convicted, the government is looking for the other conspirators. Meanwhile the young man that was caught, convicted and sentenced will serve a stiff prison term.  Both countries are considered allies to the West. However only one country is a society built upon laws that protect its citizens, no matter the religion, ethnic background, or whether it is the majority of the population or the minority of the population. The other country is a society built upon laws that protect the governing class and the majority of the population at the expense of all of its citizens. Israel understand that for Democracy to function, a government must protect its citizens even if those citizens have a different and perhaps threatening belief system. Saudi Arabia understand that for despotism to exist, there can be no tolerance for challenging the kingdom.  In the long run, which society stand a better chance of surviving the tumult and chaos of the Middle East?
In this week’s Parsha, Va’eira, we read of the importance of leadership while avoiding arrogance. We read of leaders remaining in touch with Amchah (the people), even when Amchah doesn’t listen, fails to cooperate and even challenges the leadership. We read of the terrible results when leadership becomes arrogant, out of touch, and without a sense of limits. We learn that seven times Moshe and Aharon went before Pharaoh and asked that B’nai Yisroel be freed in order to serve God in the wilderness. Seven times Pharaoh’s heart hardens and he refuses. The Parsha begins with G-d telling Moshe of the covenant, and that although he revealed himself to Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov; he did so with a different name (Ex. 6:3). Therefore, we can surmise that Moshe had a very different type of revelation and relationship with G-d than our forefathers.
This different relationship manifests itself in the conversation that transpires in Ex.6:10-13. “Then the Lord spoke to Moshe saying: Go and tell Pharaoh King of Egypt to let B’nai Yisroel out of his land. But Moshe spoke before the Lord saying: Look, B’nai Yisroel have not heeded me; how then will Pharaoh heed me, seeing I am of uncircumcised lips? So the Lord spoke to Moshe and Aharon and commanded them to B’nai Yisroel and Pharaoh King of Egypt to bring the children of Israel out of Egypt.” God never spoke this way to any of the Avot (Avraham Yitzchak and Yaakov). Nor did they speak to God like Moshe. While there are many ways to understand God’s response to a dejected Moshe, certainly one way is within the context of leadership. God essentially tells Moshe to get back out there with his brother and do what needs to be done. God also tells Moshe, that both he and Aharon must first go to their constituency even before confronting Pharaoh. Why go to B’nai Yisroel? They don’t listen and they don’t pay attention. Besides, the authority that Moshe and Aharon must confront is Pharaoh, not B’nai Yisroel. Moshe and Aharon must remain in touch with the people, even if that means increased frustration and diminished efficiency in achieving the ultimate goal.
God implicitly tells Moshe that humility is required for leadership. Rambam re-iterates this in a specific ruling: “It is forbidden for a person to lord it over the community in a domineering manner but he must exercise his authority with humility and reverence; it is likewise forbidden to treat the people with disrespect even if they are ignorant… Though they may be ordinary common folk, they are the children of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov…. He [the leader] should rather bear patiently the cumbrance of the community and their burden…Look at Moshe…God gave them a charge to Israel which our tradition takes to mean that  Moshe and Aharon accepted the yoke of leadership of the people on the understanding that they will curse and stone them.” This first step in humble leadership is acknowledgment of limitations. Hence, we read Ani Adonai, “I am the Lord”, seven times in the Parsha. Moshe and Aharon should never forget that. While it may be humbling for the leader to admit that there is still a greater being, it is even more humbling for any leader to admit that he/she must also be answerable to the people. Moshe and Aharon learn this lesson. Pharaoh does not.
Democracy is predicated upon the idea that leadership must be subject to the same laws as the citizenry.  The government, the majority cannot “lord itself” over the community in a domineering dictatorial manner. From a dictator’s perspective this is certainly inefficient and perhaps even “messy”. However when a government and/or the ruling class forget that, and lord itself over the community for a long enough time corruption increases and ultimately society grows unstable. Whatever frequent, irrational, and illogical criticism of Israel; it has been fascinating to watch how quiet the world has been in criticizing Israel about this particular trial and its results. For a change, the world seems to be more aware of the intra-Islamic fight between Shia and Sunni that has been going on for centuries and has reared its ugly sectarian head yet again as tensions between Iran and Saudi Arabia continue to increase.
Peace,
Rav Yitz