Showing posts with label the future. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the future. Show all posts

Thursday, July 15, 2021

So I Give You My Eyes And All Of Their Lies, Please Help Them To Learn (John Barlow & Bob Weir - "Black Throated Wind")

          For the past few weeks, I have followed the latest in the cultural wars. The latest battlefront is the response to Critical Race Theory (CRT). Essentially Critical Race Theory suggests that social and legal institutions created by a white-dominated social and legal institution are intrinsically racist or racially insensitive to people of colour. This theory originated in law schools as a way of challenging the racial bias that occurs anywhere. The recent battle that we have been hearing about is not the CRT per se, but the assumption that unless CRT is eliminated, little white children will be taught a version of history that might make them either feel bad about themselves, somehow makes them less appreciative of their society or even unpatriotic. Obviously, the perpetrators of this highly emotional and utterly chaotic response are those incredibly hypersensitive white people who are afraid to acknowledge the past and are certainly anti-intellectual enough that they are incapable of learning from the past. Just imagine if Moshe had to bring that group into Eretz Canaan!

          This week’s Parsha is Devarim, which is the first Parsha of the Book of Deuteronomy or Sefer Devarim. In very large brushstrokes, Moshe recounts the experiences of the generation that fled Egypt. Very few details are given. In fact, Moshe begins the story at the foot of Sinai; however, the name is changed from Sinai to Horev. In his recounting, Moshe speaks as a participant in this national experience not in the third person, as was presented in the Books of Exodus, Leviticus, and Numbers. This is quite different from the Moshe we have seen. Until now he spoke as a prophet. God spoke to him and he spoke to B'nai Yisroel. Now Moshe displays a certain amount of freedom as he shares the experiences of the past from his perspective. Parsha Devarim is the introductory Parsha to Moshe’s formal teaching of the Torah to this new generation. Moshe begins with a history lesson beginning with the most recent events and working backward to the Exodus. Moshe Rabeinu, now only a few weeks from the moment of his death, imparts his teaching and his wisdom upon B’nai Yisroel like a dying grandparent or parent would to his/her children.  This re-telling or repetition of history and laws to a new generation inspired the Talmudic Sages to call Sefer Devarim (The Book of Words- Deuteronomy) the Mishnah Torah or the repetition of the Torah. 

          Moshe does not whitewash anything. He is not terribly worried about offending historical sensitivities. While addressing this generation who is about to enter Eretz Canaan, he holds no punches. He points out that their parents and grandparents were unworthy. He points out that their parents and grandparents were spiritually weak. The first issue that Moshe discusses is the reason for wandering forty years. He recounts the incident 40 years earlier with the twelve spies. Moshe does not sugarcoat their parents and grandparents' response to the spies' report.  V’Lo Avitem La’Alot VaTamru et Pi HaShem Elokeichem But you did not wish to ascend, and you rebelled against the word of Hashem, your God. VaTeiragnu V’A’Haleichem VaTomru B’Sinat HaShem Otanu HoTzi’Anu M’Eretz Mitzrayim LaTeit Otanu B’Yad Ha’Emori L’Hashmideinu- You slandered in your tents and said, ‘because of the Hashem’s hatred for us did he take us out of the land of Egypt, to deliver us into the hand of the Amorite to destroy us.” (Deut. 1:26-27). Who is the “you” that Moshe refers to? Clearly, he is speaking to the generation that is physically before him, that is with him on the eastern bank of the Jordan River preparing to realize the covenant. Is Moshe confused? It seems doubtful. Clearly, he is talking about the parents and grandparents of the current generation. Why does he address them as “You”? Clearly, Moshe is not too terribly worried about hurting feelings, destroying love of country, or creating anti-patriotic feelings, nor is Moshe concerned about self-loathing. No, Moshe had one very real concern. If the generation that experienced the miracle of the Exodus, the Revelation at Sinai, Miriam’s Well, Manna, and God’s constant presence,  could lack faith, then each and every generation after could also lack faith. So, Moshe wanted this current generation to learn from their parents' and grandparents' mistakes and not repeat them. By referring to this generation as “you”, Moshe has inserted them into the past and holds them responsible for the future. 

          When I listen to the critics of Critical Race Theory and their fear of teaching history so that everything is whitewashed (no pun intended); I realize that is so antithetical to Judaism. First of all, how do we teach Jewish History? Our history is not only a history of oppression at the hands of dominant and frequently anti-semitism, the Rabbinic Sages look at history as self-inflicted wounds, and shortcomings in faith (Tisha B’Av and the destruction of the First and Second Temples), as well as moments when we rose to such challenges. Judaism does not have saints. Moshe points out that our ancestors had real shortcomings, Moshe had a nasty temper, King David committed numerous morally questionable acts (and paid the price for those morally questionable deeds), King Solomon had numerous non-Jewish women in his concubine that led him to engage in idolatry. Joseph’s brothers conspired against their father and lied to him about Joseph. In the Talmud, our sages record the majority opinion and the minority opinion. Judaism doesn’t whitewash anything. We struggle with the words, we struggle with the text, we interpret, we re-interpret, and interpret some more. Our Sages understood and established a tradition of learning from the successes and the failures of those who preceded us. For our Sages, the reward for learning these lessons was a vibrant Jewish society built upon learning, a society that took care of its most vulnerable, and a society that aspired towards holiness. Maybe all those overly sensitive white parents need to be reminded that the purpose of studying history is not about making sure that their fragile egos are soothed or that their fragile children feel good, but rather learn from the past in order to take responsibility for the future.

Peace
Rav Yitz 

Thursday, October 10, 2019

Looks As Though Tomorrow I'll Do Pretty Much The Same (Robert Hunter & Jerry Garcia - "Mission In The Rain")


Given all the turmoil going on in the world. Iran’s bombing of a Saudi oil field, Israel elections and inability to create a governing coalition, phone calls with Ukraine, pulling out of Syria and leaving the Kurds unprotected, an Impeachment investigation, Brexit, and elections here in Canada, let’s just say that I have some anxiety about the future in the “macro” sense of the word. I have a concern about the future over which I have no control. In our home, we are also experiencing some anxiety about the future or at least the next four or five years. With a daughter in Grade 12 (12th grade if you speak American), Shabbat and Holiday meals with friends and family always include a question directed at her. “So, grade 12, that’s terrific, what are your plans for next year?” With that simple, innocent, innocuous question are daughter understands that she actually needs to think about this next stage of her life. I remind her that we call this idea, “The Future”.   She understands that she needs to make some self-assessments and ask herself some questions: What are her academic interests, does she want to take a Gap year in Israel? If so, which program and will that program offer credit that is accepted by a university? Does she want to attend university in Ontario or the Northeast United States? If she wants to go to university in the U.S., then she needs to sign up for standardized tests and study for these tests. There are a lot of decisions and it is incredibly overwhelming and without a plan, it is paralyzing.  The good news for our daughter is that her parents went through it, her older sisters went through it and even her aunts and uncles all went through it. Her friends at school and her friends from camp are also going through it. So she is not alone. When her mother and I have tried to discuss “The Future, and her Plan”, she smiles at us and, blessed with a biting wit and great sense of humor, she says in her most dead-panned delivery, “I plan to take next year off preparing for my gap year.” I smile and ask how she intends to finance her year of gap year preparation? We all laugh but we realize that we need to get our daughter to be more excited about the future rather than anxious and dreading it.
This Shabbat, we read from Parshat Ha’Azinu. The Parsha is poetry, a song that God had commanded Moshe to compose in the previous Parsha, VaYeleich. Composing this song was the final deed that God commanded Moshe. The song is the final prophecy that God told Moshe in the previous Parsha, VaYeilech.  As a song, it does not contain the most pleasant of lyrics, and it is not particularly uplifting or inspiration. The song does not offer such an optimistic future.  Rather, Moshe invokes Heaven and Earth to offer testimony to God’s prophecy and future punishment against his people.  Throughout Sefer Devarim, Deuteronomy, Moshe has taught the law and inspired B’nai Yisroel to choose fidelity to God and God’s Torah.  Choosing to follow would result in a reward. Choosing not to follow would result in a punishment. Now, during the final moments of Moshe Rabeinu’s life, the song suggests neither choice nor the results of that choice. Instead, we are told that we will choose badly and that we will be punished.  There is nothing explicit within the song that suggests or even offers a means by which we can do Teshuva (repent) and ultimately return to God. While intellectually, Moshe has taught that concept to B’nai Yisroel; here in the song that possibility is not explicit.
Only when he completes writing the song,  Moshe then transmits his words to B’nai Yisroel. His words offer a sense of hope, a sense of inspiration. He reminds B’nai Yisroel that even when they have grown distant from God, even though the resulting punishment will be brutal; there is still a measure of hope, hope for the next generation.  Simu Levavchem L’Chol Hadvarim Asher Anochi Mei’id Bachem Hayom, Asher T’Tzavoom et Bnaichem Lishmor La’Asot et Kol Divrei HaTorah Ha’Zot -  Apply your hearts to all the words that I Testify against you today, with which you are to instruct your children, to be careful to perform all the words of this Torah.  Ki Lo Davar Reik Hu Mikem Ki Hu Chayeichem Uvadavar HaZeh Ta’Arichu Yamim – for it is not an empty thing for you, for it is your life, and through this matter shall you prolong your days on the Land to which you cross the Jordan to possess it. In Moshe’s final moments, he reminds us that the key to our survival is to teach Torah to our children. Yes, according to the song, we will grow distant from God, yes we will engage in idolatry. Yes, we will be punishment. However, there will always be hope for the next generation if they are educated in such a manner that when it comes time for them to make a choice; they choose wisely, they choose God’s Torah.  Moshe reminds his people that the Torah is not empty. Rashi reminds us that if we find Torah to be empty and unsatisfying then the fault lies with us, Mikem.
Rashi seems to be empowering us. If the fault lies with us, then we have it within our power to do something about it. Parsha HaAzinu is always read at this time of year, a time when the Jewish people have stood before God to be judged for past behavior as well as received the message that the future is NOT set in concrete. Our behavior, our deeds can affect our future. I can see why some may find that to be an overbearing weight. At the same time, I find such empowerment to offer a bit of hope in dealing with the future. Sensing our daughter’s avoidance of dealing with the future by joking about a “gap year to prepare for a gap year”, we tried to think of something within our control that might help alter her outlook, something that would allow her to see herself in the future. Since our daughter was planning on spending the final days of the Sukkot Festival in New Jersey, we decided that I would pick her up and on our way home we would stop at a few University Campuses. Hopefully, just walking around, getting a tour, and speaking to with the admissions department, at least she will have a sense that the future is not as daunting as perhaps she envisions.  
Peace,
Rav Yitz

Wednesday, December 31, 2014

The Future's Here, We Are It, We Are On Our Own (John Barlow & Bob Weir - "Throwing Stones")



We just returned from a week long family holiday. We drove to New York City. We spent the conclusion of Chanukah and the days leading up to last Shabbat with Manhattan. We stayed with my sister and her family in their apartment. We spent time with our eldest daughter who lives and works in New York. We saw friends. We saw many of New York’s tourist attractions.  However there was a moment when I had a vision of the future, based upon two small seemingly dismissive incidents while in New York. The first incident occurred on Christmas Eve. My brother in law generously took both families, including his and my sister’s 4 year old daughter, and my family including our four children to his favorite steak restaurant. There we were, nine of us my sister and her family, me and my family. Such a gathering is very unique for us since gathering such as this include our parents. However they were back home. We ate, drank, talked and of course took a couple of pictures and sent them immediately to my parents.  When I spoke to my mother later that week, she commented how wonderful it was to see her children and their respective families gathered together spending time together. It brought her a sense of contentment and nachas seeing that. Later that evening, my children and I went to a movie down in Greenwich Village. As we walked to the subway, the four of them walked together a couple of steps ahead of me. They boarded the subway together. Even when we left the movie theatre and returned to the Upper West Side, the four of them: the 24 year old, the 14 year old, the 12 year old, and the 10 year old walked together almost as one. I watch them as I walked behind. Seeing my children walk together along the sidewalks of New York gave me a glimpse of a possible future of their lives without me. That glimpse provided me with a sense of calm about the future of my family.

This morning we read from Parsha Vayechi. This is the final Parshah in the book of Breishit. The Parsha begins with Yaakov calling Yosef and making him swear an oath that he will not be buried in Egypt. He also blesses his grandson’s Ephraim and Menashe. He gathers his sons together and offers each son a blessing or a prophecy. Yaakov dies and his sons take him out of Egypt and fulfill their vow. They bury their father in Hevron alongside Avraham and Yitzchak and Sarah Rebecca and Leah. Afterwards, the brothers fear that Yosef will finally take vengeance for their mistreatment of him. Yosef doesn’t, and the brothers and their families continue to grow and prosper in Goshen. As Yosef prepares for his death, he makes his brothers vow to take his bones out of Egypt and bury his bones in Eretz Canaan. Upon completing the Parsha, we stand and recite the words Chazak v’Nitchazeik – From strength to strength, we go forward in strength.

Immediately after Yaakov requests that he be buried in Hevron with his ancestors and then blesses Yosef’s son’s Ephraim and Menashe; the Torah tells us that he gathers the rest of his sons together in order to bless them. However the Torah manner in which Yaakov makes the request seems rather puzzling and perhaps redundant VaYikrah Yakov El Banav VaYomer - Then Jacob called for his sons and said: Hei’Asfu V’Agida Lachem Eit Asher Yikrah Etchem B’Acharit HaYamim – Assemble yourselves and I will tell you what will befall you in the End of Days. HiKavtsu v’Shimu Bnai Yaakov VShimu el Yisroel Avichem – Gather yourselves and listen, O sons of Jacob, and listen to Israel your father. (49:1-2. Yaakov tells them to “Assemble yourselves” then to “Gather yourselves. What is the difference between Hei’Asfu (Assemble yourselves) and Hikavtsu (Gather yourselves)? The former comes from the three lettered root ASaF which means to harvest.  The latter comes from the three lettered root KaVaTz which means ‘to press together’, ‘collect’. Ideally, ripe produce is harvested. Jacobs’ sons were ripe, they were spiritually ripe and ready to receive Jacob’s blessings. The survival of this family, required that the sons press together spiritually, to put aside their individual grievances and remains together otherwise the family and ultimately the nation will not survive. The rest of the Torah, and certainly the Books of Judges, Kings and Prophets reflect the struggles and tensions of trying to remain assembled and pressed together. Eventually, the future kingdom under David HaMelech will fail to remain united once his Son, Shlomo HaMelech dies. While Yaakov tried to share his vision with his sons of the “End of Days”; it must have been re-assuring that they came together, listened to their father, and prepared themselves for the impending slavery and eventual freedom of their children, grandchildren and great grandchildren.
I suppose that with families of our own, when we gather with my sister’s family or my wife’s sister’s family, it suggests a ripeness. It suggests that we are old enough physically and spiritually to appreciate the importance of HeiAsif, of Assembling ourselves together. We know that it brings nachas to our parents, to see their children and grandchildren together. When I see children HiKavtzu gathered together, they are learning that the secret to their respective family’s survival is creating bonds whereby they share the future together. Seeing my children go through gathering and assembling process gives me a hint of my of children’s possible future and the joy of watching a family grow up and thrive together.

Peace,
Rav Yitz

Monday, July 1, 2013

Truckin' I'm A Going Home Whoa, Whoa, Baby, Back Where I Belong (Robert Hunter & Jerry Garcia - "Truckin")



Well sleep away camp finally started. While it has been a busy and somewhat difficult time for our three children; our soon to be teen-ager seemed to have the most difficult time. After weeks of list making, shopping, schlepping, shopping some more, labeling, listening to the whining, and the crying about going to a place where she doesn’t know anyone and watching the fits and starts of  numerous attempts to pack, finally the moment is at hand. The kids are at camp; they are in their bunks and they are meeting their bunk mates. There have been numerous pep talks. There have been reminders of previous experiences that should provide a source strength and confidence. However I have learned that my reminding her of those experiences is not nearly as effective as her recalling those experiences and her learning to derive strength and confidence herself.

This morning we read from Parsha Matot/Masei. These are the final two parshiot of Sefer BaMidbar (Book of Numbers).  Like the end of most books, these parshiot tie up numerous loose ends. It ties up the loose ends of the narrative such as how to deal with the Midianites following episode with Pinchas, the daughters of Tzelophchad and issues of inheritance, as well as the borders of Eretz Canaan, and the Cities of Refuge. All these final issues must be dealt with since, from a narrative perspective, Bnai Yisroel is spiritually and physically ready to cross the Yarden River and enter into Eretz Canaan. Bnai Yisroel is about to realize the Brit, the covenant that God made with the Avot: Avraham, Yiztchak and Yaakov.

Whenever an individual, a group, a community or a people stand on the precipice of a realized goal; looking back upon the journey only makes sense.  Whenever an individual, a group, a community or a people experience anxiety about the ability to handle future unknowns; looking back at past lessons also seems to make a lot of sense. We look back upon the journey for a variety of reasons. First we look back upon the journey in sheer wonderment; we cannot believe we have traveled so far and finally achieved. Second, we look back upon the journey in order to provide context and meaning for all those who joined in the journey towards the middle or the end. Third, we look back upon the journey as a series of opportunities that were necessary in order to realize the stated goal. Fourth, we look back knowing that if we overcame past obstacles and fears, then we should be able to overcome future anxieties, obstacles and fears.  Eilah Masei V’nai Yisroel Asher Yatzu M’Eretz Mitztrayim L'tzivotam  B’Yad Moshe v’Aharon – These are the journeys of the Children of Israel, who went forth from the Land of Egypt according to the legions under the hand of Moshe and Aharon … V’Eilah Maseihem L’Motzaheihem – And these are the their journeys according to their departures. (Num. 33:1-2) God commanded Moshe to keep a record of their travels according to their Maseihem - destination. This is means of recording based upon positive expectations, when there were no travails, issues or problems. Moshe also kept a record of their travels based upon Motzaheihem their departures, when there were travails, issues and great difficulties, when people murmured against God, against Moshe etc. Now that Bnai Yisroel stands on the brink of entering Eretz Canaan, all the experiences, both positive and negative gave Bnai Yisroel an opportunity to learn Faith.  The journey and all that was experienced during that 40-year journey was necessary in order to arrive at this point in time.

Hopefully, as our daughter experiences her first few nights at sleep away camp, experiences the gnawing fear of wondering if she will make new friends, hopefully she will be able to recall her own journey into new and unknown experiences. Hopefully she will remember that she made friends quickly and easily when she moved to California, when she arrived here in Toronto, or when she played for her school basketball team. Hopefully she will realize that the anxiety is really in her own mind rather than in the reality of her experiences or the reality of each new day at camp.

Peace
Rav Yitz

Wednesday, December 26, 2012

And The Old Man Never Was The Same Again ( Robert Hunter & Jerry Garcia "Brown Eyed Women")



As we are on holiday, driving from Toronto to the New York metropolitan area, we always make a series of stops. We stop in Rochester to visit grandparents and a 96 year old great grandfather. We stop in New Jersey in order to visit friends. We go into the New York to visit with a sister her husband and their daughter, back to New Jersey for to visit other friends and finally a back to Rochester and then onto Toronto.  While we have just arrived in New Jersey during a snow storm, we just experienced a rather difficult moment with my 96 year old grandfather who is suffering from dementia. We arrived at the Jewish Home and went to his room. I gently woke him and I identified myself using my name and how I was related to him. Then once he was awake and lucid I brought my wife and three children into his room. He looked at my wife, he looked at me straining to recognize us; trying to figure out we were and how we are connected to him. Then he looked at our children and said “tell me who you are and how you are related to me”.  Each child dutifully stated their name and then told him that “I am your great grandchild”. My wife introduced herself and then I told him who I was and then added that “I have been your grandson for nearly 50 years.” For the next 20 minutes, we made some chit chat with my grandfather and continued re-introducing ourselves to him. No there was no light switch that went on; no clear connection was ever made
This week we read from Parsha VaYechi.  Yaakov Avinu feels that death is imminent. He feels compelled to bless Yosef’s sons. Then he asks Yosef to promise him that he, Yaakov will be buried back in Hevron with his mother, father, grandfather and grandmother. Then Yaakov calls in his son’s and begins blessing each son. He tells them what he had been told by Hashem. He shares with them the impending slavery, the ultimate redemption and the return to their covenantal land. Yaakov passed away. True to his word, Yosef arranged to have his father buried in Hebron. With help from his brothers, Yosef and his brothers brought Yaakov back to Hevron, bury him and return to Egypt. The Parsha concludes with the brothers and Yosef dying but not until we are told that Yosef managed to see his great grandchildren.
Certainly the passing of generations can certainly be construed as a sad, and in this Parsha there is not only the death of Yaakov but also the passing of the next generation, Yosef and his son’s. However there is something quite comforting in the fact that in this final parsha of Breishit, we see the first interaction between grandparents and grandchildren. It is the first time that we read about a great grandfather look out onto his great grandchildren and enjoying the satisfaction that comes with knowing that they have created and left a legacy. So when Yaakov tells Yosef: V’Atah Shnei Vanecha HaNoladim Lecha B’Aretz Mitzrayim Ad Bo’I Eilecha Mitzraymah Li Heim Efrayim U’Menashe K’Reuvein V’Shimon Yeheyu Li – And now your two sons, who were born to you in the land of Egypt before I came to you to Egypt, are mine. Efrayim and Menashe like Reuven, and Shimon shall be mine (Gen. 48:5). Clearly Yaakov knows who Yosef’s sons are. Not only that, but Yaakov readily acknowledges that he will now consider these grandchildren as his sons.  Three psukim later we learn VaYar Yisroel et Bnai Yosef Va’Yoemer Mi Eilah- Israel saw Yosef’s sons, and said ‘who are these’?  (Gen. 48-8) So what happened? Yaakov knew who Yosef’s sons were but the same man; three verses later forgot who Yosef’s sons were? Is this the first case of dementia or Alzheimer’s in the Torah? Why does Yaakov know who Yosef’s sons are but the Israel version of Yaakov doesn’t know who Yosef’s sons are? The Midrash explains that when the boys approached their dying grandfather, he wasn’t looking only at them but looking past them. He was looking into the future, past slavery in Egypt, past the return to Eretz Canaan, and to the era of Kings. Israel saw the kings of the future that came from Efrayim and Menashe and the continued deterioration of the covenant that God made with Yaakov.
Yaakov spent his life always clinging, clinging to Esav, clinging to Lavan, clinging to an angel/man during a wrestling match, cling to God, and now in his final moments, Yaakov views thinks that his life will live on in his son’s and his grandsons. Yaakov sees in his grandsons and opportunity for a brief second chance as a father. Israel doesn’t cling and grasp onto things. Israel wrestles with God and was victorious. Israel is decisive, Israel has a singular objective: insure the future of the covenant. With his grandchildren and great children about to begin their descent into slavery and his knowledge that there will be numerous times when later generations will violate the covenant, Israel hesitates to give his blessing. Israel switches his hands; Israel shows favoritism towards the grandsons. However this is not favoritism based on loving one more than the other. This is a favoritism based upon the cold stark truth of which child is best suited for insuring the survival of Israel’s values and ethical code.
When it was time to leave my grandfather, he looked at me and said “you have a beautiful family.” I leaned over to him and said “they are your family”. There was another blank look and then said, “well, if you say so.”  We said good bye and I told him “I say so.” That was probably the closest thing to a blessing that I will ever hear from him again.
Peace,
Rav Yitz